Upcoming changes in German insolvency legislation | Practical Law

Upcoming changes in German insolvency legislation | Practical Law

This article is part of the PLC Global Finance January 2011 e-mail update for Germany.

Upcoming changes in German insolvency legislation

Practical Law Legal Update 6-504-6311 (Approx. 3 pages)

Upcoming changes in German insolvency legislation

by Sandra Pfister and Ingrid Kalisch, Simmons & Simmons
Published on 31 Jan 2011Germany

Speedread

The restructuring of highly leveraged and complex debt structures in recent times has kick-started a review of existing insolvency regimes in a number of European jurisdictions, among them Germany. The German review is aimed at facilitating and speeding up business rescue processes thus allowing for easier restructuring of financial indebtedness.
The proposed legislative changes aimed at facilitating and speeding up business rescue processes in Germany include:

Encouragement to negotiate debt restructurings prior to the commencement of insolvency proceedings

The first trend that emerged relates to the desire to encourage the debtor and its key creditors to negotiate the terms of a debt restructuring before the debtor enters into a more extensive insolvency procedure. In this regards, the proposed legislation contemplates the introduction of pre-insolvency restructuring proceedings, which would allow a debtor for a period of up to three months to develop and negotiate an insolvency plan with its creditors, subject to the protection of a statutory moratorium – a quasi German "chapter 11".

Setting a tight timetable for agreement of pre-negotiated restructurings

Under the proposed German legislation, a debtor choosing to initiate pre-insolvency restructuring proceedings will be granted a period of not more than three months in which to develop and negotiate an insolvency plan with its creditors.

Encouraging debtors to initiate restructuring negotiations while still cashflow positive

Under the proposed German legislation, the ability of debtors to pre-negotiate a restructuring with some degree of court protection would be conditional on the debtor having sufficient liquidity to meet its ongoing costs and expenses during the negotiation process. Also, the court would have the power to cut short the pre-insolvency restructuring period if the debtor becomes insolvent.

Strengthening the "debtor in possession" concept

The proposed legislative changes are intended to encourage the debtor's management to act early in order to address the financial challenges facing the company and the amended German self administration regime would allow the debtor's management to remain in control of the debtor's business while the restructuring is being negotiated, subject to a certain degree of supervision by a court-appointed trustee, the Sachwalter tasked with reviewing and facilitating the restructuring process.

Reducing the influence of dissenting creditors

Under the proposed German legislation, majority creditors would be able to influence the choice of the insolvency administrator (and thus the likely path of the restructuring process). Moreover, in considering whether to grant a self administration petition, the court would generally be required to follow the majority creditors' wishes. Also, the proposed reforms would limit those minority creditors' powers to object to an insolvency plan, unless they can show that:
  • The plan puts them into a materially worse position compared to the position they would be in without the plan.
  • Creditors cannot be compensated for a worse position by a payment specifically provided for in the insolvency plan.
  • The right of an individual creditor to seek the termination of the self administration process would be limited.