Individual flood protection measures: new EA template report for insurers | Practical Law

Individual flood protection measures: new EA template report for insurers | Practical Law

The Environment Agency has released a template report for property owners to use when installing flood protection measures. The report draws together information on the flood risk (with and without the measures) and can be used in negotiations with insurers when arranging flood cover. (Free access.)

Individual flood protection measures: new EA template report for insurers

Practical Law UK Legal Update 1-522-1091 (Approx. 7 pages)

Individual flood protection measures: new EA template report for insurers

by PLC Property
Published on 29 Oct 2012England, Wales
The Environment Agency has released a template report for property owners to use when installing flood protection measures. The report draws together information on the flood risk (with and without the measures) and can be used in negotiations with insurers when arranging flood cover. (Free access.)

Speedread

The Environment Agency has released a template report for property owners to use when installing flood protection measures in their property. The template has been welcomed by the Association of British Insurers as helping to set out the flood risk information which insurers may ask for. The hope is that the report will both reassure property owners that the measures taken will have a positive effect and assist insurers in deciding whether to offer flood cover and on what terms.
If you don’t yet subscribe to PLC, you can request a free trial by completing this form or contacting the PLC Helpline.

Background

There are many factors leading to the increasing prevalence of flooding in the UK. It may be caused by overflowing rivers, tidal surges, or (more often) by surface water run off collecting in large quantities. The problem has been made worse because building on flood plains was not discouraged by the planning system until recently.
Insurers have access to ever more sophisticated data about the location, depth and predicted frequency of all types of flooding, so can use this when deciding whether to offer flood cover or not, and on what terms. For some time, an agreement between the government and the Association of British Insurers (ABI) has helped to keep flood cover available for homes and small business properties and reduce the premiums chargeable for properties at risk of flooding. This is called the Statement of Principles. It expires in June 2013 and will not be renewed.
The government is discussing with the ABI what alternative scheme (if any) can be agreed to keep flood cover available and affordable for owners of properties that are at risk. Their decision is considerably overdue (originally planned for Spring 2012), partly because current austerity measures mean that the government does not wish to become insurer of last resort for such properties. It is unlikely that any scheme agreed will apply to all properties at risk, or will prevent insurers from setting higher excesses or other conditions for such insurance.
A property owner or occupier may be able to reduce the risk of flooding by installing flood protection measures in the property. These measures are referred to as property level protection (PLP). This may improve the ability of the property owner or occupier to obtain flood insurance or reduce the excess that is charged. Flood protection measures will differ depending on the nature of the property, the likely cause of flooding and its predicted depth. Not all flooding can be prevented by such measures, which fall into two types:
  • Flood resistance measures (which keep the flood waters out of the building).
  • Flood resilience measures (which help the property dry out more quickly and with less lasting damage).
For more details on the issues affecting flood insurance, see:

Environment Agency and Defra template report

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) has been collaborating with the Environment Agency (EA), ABI, the British Insurance Brokers' Association (BIBA), the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) and others (including PLC Property) to develop a template report that draws together the information on property level protection installed at a property.
The Environment Agency has today released:
  • The template report (called a "Flood Risk Report"), which recommends what can be done to reduce the flood risk to the property (see The content of the report). It is sometimes referred to as the "post-installation report" to distinguish it from the report that will be done before the PLP measures are installed.
  • Guidance to surveyors or engineers on how to complete the template flood risk report.
  • Two examples of completed reports for properties at risk of river flooding (see example one and example two).
These documents will be revised and updated in response to comments and user feedback.

Aims of the template flood risk report

The parties involved in development of the documents intend the template flood risk report to give:
  • Homeowners, businesses and insurers a clear description of the PLP measures installed at a property and information on the flood risk that these address.
  • Property owners a record of the PLP measures at their property which is easy to share (with tenants and subsequent purchasers). The guidance suggests that the report is kept with the title deeds.
  • Insurers and insurance brokers relevant information on PLP measures in a standardised format, to help them consider insurance availability and pricing.
The guidance stresses that insurance practice will vary and that there is no guarantee that the information in the report will improve the insurance terms offered by any particular insurer. However, the ABI and BIBA have endorsed the report as a useful initiative (see Endorsements for the template report).

The surveyor's role

A flood risk report is intended to be completed by a professional, suitably qualified, independent surveyor, who may be engaged by the:
  • Property owner (if they are installing their own PLP measures);
  • Local authority or Lead Local Flood Authority (where the PLP measures are part of a wider scheme applicable to several properties);
  • Environment Agency (where the PLP measures are part of a flood protection scheme coordinated by them)
In some cases, local authority, Lead Local Flood Authority or Environment Agency schemes may use an in-house surveyor, or project manager, to produce the report.
The report is to be given to the property owner and the guidance encourages them to share the information in it with their tenants (for example, the advice on proper fitting of any demountable PLP measures, such as flood gates or toilet bungs).

The significance for lawyers

Lawyers will not become involved in preparing flood risk reports, but may come across them in any of the following ways:
  • When acting on a purchase of a property that has PLP measures installed. Here it will be prudent to ask for a copy of the flood risk report (which the seller should have with its deeds).
  • When advising a client who is considering installing PLP measures (either following disclosure, on due diligence, of a potential risk of flooding, or following actual flooding, when the client may wish to take precautions against any repeat episode). The client should ideally seek proper advice on what PLP measures to instal, and commission a flood risk report after the work is done.
  • Where the lawyer is helping a client to obtain flood insurance for buildings or contents and the terms offered are unattractive because the insurer considers the property to have a high risk of flooding. Supplying a copy of the flood risk report to the broker or insurer may provide some reassurance that the risk has been reduced.

The content of the report

The report has 5 sections and a glossary. Where the surveyor does not have the relevant information or part of a section is inapplicable, then the surveyor can simply state this in the report.
This report will be completed after the PLP measures have been installed. It anticipates the property owner will have had an initial survey done (called the pre-installation survey) to identify the flood risk and recommend potential PLP measures.
There is no template for a pre-installation survey. It may be a bespoke report prepared by a qualified flooding engineer, a survey done by a company specialising in PLP measures, a desktop flood search or something less formal. For more detail about flood searches, see Practice note, Flood Risk Searches.

Section 1: The standard of protection from flooding offered by the PLP measures

PLP measures do not reduce the flood risk applicable to the property (which is a measure of the likely frequency of flooding in that particular area, its likely depth and the particular threshold levels of that property. This is covered in Section 3 of the report). Instead PLP measures provide protection against the effects of that flooding (keeping the water out or reducing its effects).
This section records the maximum flooding against which the PLP measures should provide protection. It is measured in annual probability (the chance that flooding of this depth will occur in any given year). For more details on annual probability of flooding, see Practice note, Flood Risk Searches: Classification of Risk Levels.
This section also describes what PLP measures were recommended and confirms that the surveyor has inspected these (so far as possible) to confirm they have been installed. Finally, the section gives some practical information about:
  • Whether the property is detached, semi detached or terraced. This can be very important, as properties that are connected to each other will often need to collaborate about PLP measures, for them to be effective.
  • Whether the current owner is a member of a community flood group. Insurers may find this reassuring because it will indicate that the owner is aware of the action that is needed when flooding is threatened, and this can minimise consequent losses.
  • Whether the EA provides a flood warning service for this community for river/coastal flooding.

Section 2: The PLP measures installed

The various measures are listed here, divided into resistance measures that have to be installed manually, resistance measures which are automatic and resilience measures. This is accompanied by a reminder that correct storage and maintenance may be critical for the correct operation of PLP measures.

Section 3: Flood risk information for the property

This section records the flood risk applicable to this property from the four main sources of flooding (river, coastal, groundwater and surface water) and any others that may be applicable. The summary table records the lowest level of flooding that will cause flooding to this particular property (again expressed in terms of annual probability). More detail is then given for each type of flooding that is relevant, showing the depth of that flooding at ground, threshold and airbrick levels, for a range of annual probabilities.

Section 4: Flood history of the property

If information is available to the surveyor on past flooding that has affected the property, it can be entered here.

Section 5: guidance for the property owner and tenants

This section has standard guidance on what to do with the report and where to find more information.

Endorsements for the template report

These organisations have endorsed the template report:
“The ABI welcomes the publication of a standard template for surveying property-level flood risk. Our members have helped to develop the template and are confident that it will give surveyors a recognised framework for assessing a complex and variable risk, and will help consumers set out the flood risk information that insurers may ask them to provide.” (ABI.)
“BIBA welcomes this approach and believes it will bring benefits to the way customers share information on property level protection with the insurance industry. We are making our members aware of this approach and have asked them to consider this information where it is available.” (BIBA.)
“The RICS welcome having a single method for post installation reporting as this will help the industry to respond to the growing challenge of flood management. Its members will be available to assist users of the report with information on the various flood resistance and resilience measures available” (RICS.)