European Commission publishes amendments extending MAD II to benchmark manipulation | Practical Law

European Commission publishes amendments extending MAD II to benchmark manipulation | Practical Law

The European Commission has published proposals to amend its MAD II legislative proposals to ensure that they cover the manipulation of benchmarks, such as LIBOR, and that manipulation of benchmarks is a criminal offence. (Free access.)

European Commission publishes amendments extending MAD II to benchmark manipulation

Practical Law UK Legal Update 3-520-5820 (Approx. 4 pages)

European Commission publishes amendments extending MAD II to benchmark manipulation

by PLC Financial Services
Published on 25 Jul 2012European Union
The European Commission has published proposals to amend its MAD II legislative proposals to ensure that they cover the manipulation of benchmarks, such as LIBOR, and that manipulation of benchmarks is a criminal offence. (Free access.)

Speedread

On 25 July 2012 the European Commission published proposed amendments to its proposals for a Regulation on insider dealing and market manipulation (MAR) and a Directive on criminal sanctions for insider dealing and market manipulation (CSMAD) (collectively MAD II).
The Commission's proposals follow revelations concerning the possible manipulation of the EURIBOR and LIBOR benchmarks. The amendments are intended to bring the manipulation of benchmarks within the scope of MAD II and to ensure that manipulation of markets becomes a criminal offence.
For more information on MAD II, see Practice note, Hot topics: MAD II.
On 25 July 2012 the European Commission published on its website proposed amendments to its proposals for a Regulation on insider dealing and market manipulation (MAR) and a Directive on criminal sanctions for insider dealing and market manipulation (CSMAD) (collectively MAD II). The amendments are intended to bring the manipulation of benchmarks within the scope of MAD II.
The Commission has published the following documents:

Background

The Commission published its MAD II legislative proposals in October 2011. MAD II will replace the existing Market Abuse Directive (2003/6/EC) (MAD) with a new Directive and Regulation: CSMAD and MAR. For more information, see Legal updates, European Commission publishes legislative proposals for Regulation on market abuse and Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse and Market abuse: Commission proposal for new regulation and directive (corporate aspects).
Following revelations concerning the possible manipulation of the EURIBOR and LIBOR benchmarks, the Commission has assessed whether the manipulation benchmarks, including EURIBOR and LIBOR, would be captured by the MAD II proposals and concluded that the direct manipulation of benchmarks would not fall within the scope of CSMAD or MAR.

Proposed amendments to MAD II

The amendments proposed by the Commission to CSMAD and MAR are intended to bring the direct manipulation of benchmarks within the scope of MAD II and to ensure that the direct manipulation of benchmarks becomes a criminal offence. For details of the amendments, see Amendments to MAR and Amendments to CSMAD below.
For these purposes a benchmark is defined as "any commercial index or published figure calculated by the application of a formula to the value of one or more underlying assets or prices, including estimated prices, interest rates or other values, or surveys by reference to which the amount payable under a financial instrument is determined". This definition is an expanded version of the definition used in the proposed Markets in Financial Instruments Regulation (MiFIR).
The FAQs state that underlying assets or prices referenced in benchmarks can include equities (such as the FTSE 100 index), bonds (such as NASDAQ OMX fixed income), interest rates (such as LIBOR or EURIBOR), or commodities such as agricultural products metals or oil and that all benchmarks are included in the amended proposal, provided that these determine the amount payable under a financial instrument.
The Commission intends for the European Parliament and the Council of the EU to consider these proposals as part of their work on MAD II, with a view to adopting a report and general approach respectively on MAD II in autumn 2012.

Amendments to MAR

The Commission is proposing to amend:
  • The scope of MAR to include benchmarks (Article 2).
  • The definitions used in MAR to include a definition of benchmarks (Article 5).
  • The definition of the offence of market manipulation to capture manipulation of benchmarks and attempts at such manipulation (Article 8).

Amendments to CSMAD

The Commission is proposing to amend:
  • The definitions used in CSMAD to include a definition of benchmarks (Article 2).
  • The offence of market manipulation to capture manipulation of benchmarks (Article 4).
  • The offence of "inciting, aiding and abetting and attempt" to include these behaviours in relation to the manipulation of benchmarks (Article 5).
The main aim of the amendments to CSMAD is to ensure that there are criminal sanctions for the manipulation of benchmarks.
For more information on MAD II, see Practice note, Hot topics: MAD II.
If you do not yet subscribe to PLC, you can request a free trial by completing this form or contacting the PLC Helpline.