Shareholder Proposals Toolkit | Practical Law

Shareholder Proposals Toolkit | Practical Law

Resources to assist counsel in assessing shareholder proposals and related considerations.

Shareholder Proposals Toolkit

Practical Law Toolkit w-014-2432 (Approx. 5 pages)

Shareholder Proposals Toolkit

by Practical Law Corporate & Securities
MaintainedUSA (National/Federal)
Resources to assist counsel in assessing shareholder proposals and related considerations.
Each year public companies receive proposals from shareholders to be included in company proxy materials requesting that the company take certain actions. A shareholder proposal is a recommendation or requirement that a company or its board of directors take a particular action, which is submitted by a shareholder for consideration at a meeting of the company's shareholders.
There are two methods by which shareholders can raise their own proposals at a meeting of company shareholders:
  • Under applicable state law and in accordance with the company's charter and by-laws.
  • Under Rule 14a-8 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Rule 14a-8 is only applicable to reporting companies that have a class of securities registered under Section 12 of the Exchange Act.
A shareholder relying on state law and a company's organizational documents must develop its own proxy materials and conduct its own proxy solicitation, which can be an expensive and burdensome process. Conversely, proposals made under Rule 14a-8 are included in the company's proxy statement and on the company proxy ballot alongside management's proposals.
If a shareholder submits a proposal under Rule 14a-8 that complies with specified eligibility and procedural requirements, and is not excludable for substantive reasons, a company is required to:
  • Include the shareholder proposal and related supporting statement in its proxy statement and list the shareholder proposal on its proxy card.
  • Submit the proposal to a vote at the shareholders' meeting along with the company's proposals.
The subjects of these shareholder proposals range from corporate governance matters, such as a majority vote for the election of directors, to social issues, such as climate change or corporate political spending.
Companies are required to include Rule 14a-8 shareholder proposals in their proxy materials unless they can demonstrate either one or both of the following:
  • The proponent or proposal, as the case may be, does not adhere to the rule's procedural requirements.
  • The proposal falls within one or more of the rule's substantive bases for exclusion.
This Toolkit sets out resources that provide an overview of the Rule 14a-8 shareholder proposal process from the perspective of companies and a framework to guide and inform the analysis of shareholder proposals and related matters and processes.