2014 Budget: key environmental announcements | Practical Law

2014 Budget: key environmental announcements | Practical Law

A summary of the main environmental announcements in the 2014 Budget, delivered by the Chancellor of the Exchequer on 19 March 2014. (Free access.)

2014 Budget: key environmental announcements

Practical Law UK Legal Update 9-561-2986 (Approx. 13 pages)

2014 Budget: key environmental announcements

Published on 19 Mar 2014England, Wales
A summary of the main environmental announcements in the 2014 Budget, delivered by the Chancellor of the Exchequer on 19 March 2014. (Free access.)

Speedread

This update summarises the main environmental announcements in the 2014 Budget, delivered by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, on 19 March 2014.
For further analysis from Practical Law of other aspects of the 2014 Budget, see Practical Law: 2014 Budget.

Measures to support energy intensive industries

Overview

Manufacturing is playing a key role in the UK's economic recovery. The 2014 Budget includes measures to ensure secure and affordable energy for businesses because the cost of energy acutely impacts the international competitiveness of the manufacturing export sector, particularly for energy intensive industries (EIIs). Around 80% of EIIs are based in the north of England, Scotland and Wales.
A recent survey by EEF (the manufacturers' organisation) cited rising input costs, mainly energy costs, as the most significant risk to growth for manufacturing in 2014-15.
A typical EII in the UK currently pays almost 50% more for its electricity than its equivalent in France. The policies to deliver new low carbon energy infrastructure are set to increase energy costs to business by around 300% by 2020. There are particular concerns that EIIs in the UK will relocate to countries with lower input costs (carbon leakage).
As a result, the 2014 Budget announces a package of reforms to reduce the cost of energy for business (particularly for manufacturing) while improving security of supply and maintaining the government's ambition to increase renewable energy generation.
The government believes these reforms will benefit the whole of the UK by saving a total of up to £7 billion by 2018-19. This will particularly benefit the most energy intensive manufacturers.
(Budget Report, paragraph 1.106.)

Carbon price floor (CPF)

Background

As part of the government's Electricity Market Reform (EMR), the carbon price floor (CPF) will provide an incentive for operators to move away from high carbon technologies, by increasing the price paid for emitting carbon dioxide through taxing fossil fuels used for electricity generation. The CPF has been implemented through amendments to the climate change levy (CCL) and the fuel duty.
Carbon price support (CPS) rates of the CCL apply to fossil fuels used in electricity generation that are taxed under the CCL regime (gas, solid fuels and liquefied petroleum gas).
For more information on the EMR and CPF in general, see Practice note, Electricity Market Reform (EMR): Carbon price floor.

CPF cap

The government indicates in the 2014 Budget that the UK-only element of the CPF will be capped at £18 per tonne of carbon dioxide from 2016-17 to 2019-20. This will have the effect of freezing the CPS rates for each of the individual taxable commodities across this period at around 2015-16 levels.
The government indicates that, while it remains committed to the CPF as a means to stimulate investment in low carbon infrastructure, this cap will limit any competitive disadvantage to UK companies. This could save UK businesses up to £4 billion by 2018-19 and £15 off a typical household energy bill in 2018-19.
(Budget Report, paragraphs 1.106 and 2.162.)
The government believes it is vital to reform and strengthen the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS), including by agreeing to the new ambitious EU climate and energy package for 2030 (see Legal update, European Commission publishes proposed 2030 climate and energy framework: environmental implications). The government will review the CPF trajectory for the 2020s (including whether a continued cap on the CPS rate might be necessary) once it is clearer how the EU ETS will be reformed. For more information on the EU ETS in general, see EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) toolkit.

Exemption of fuel used in CHP plants for electricity generated to supply manufacturing firms from the CPF

From 1 April 2015, the government will exempt from the CPF fuels used to generate good quality electricity by combined heat and power (CHP) plants for on-site purposes.
(Budget Report, paragraphs 1.109 and 2.163.)

CPF technical changes

As announced in December 2013, the government will amend the CPF rate for coal and other fossil fuels for 2014-15 and 2015-16. The government will also make kerosene used in electricity generation liable to tax from 1 May 2014.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.164.)

Hydrocarbon Oil Duties (Reliefs for Electricity Generation) (Amendments for Carbon Price Support) Regulations 2014

The Hydrocarbon Oil Duties (Reliefs for Electricity Generation) (Amendments for Carbon Price Support) Regulations 2014 (SI 2014/713) implement the key changes to the CPF by amending the Hydrocarbon Oil Duties (Reliefs for Electricity Generation) Regulations 2005 (SI 2005/3320), which introduced a relief from excise duty for rebated oils used to produce electricity.
From 1 April 2013, such relief has been reduced by the CPS rates of fuel duty. These Regulations re-affirm the CPS rates from 1 April 2014 to 31 March 2016, and set the rates from 1 April 2016. They also apply the rates to kerosene used to produce electricity from 1 May 2014.
The Regulations are accompanied by an explanatory memorandum.

Exemption from renewable energy support extended from CFDs to RO and FITs

Contracts for Difference (CFDs) form an important part of the EMR. The government has already announced that it will introduce a new compensation scheme, from 2016-17, to help EIIs with higher electricity costs resulting from subsidies for renewable electricity generation under CFDs when they are fully introduced (see Practice note, Electricity Market Reform (EMR): Exemption for energy-intensive industries (EIIs)).
The government has announced in the 2014 Budget that it will extend this exemption, from 2016-17, to include an exemption from the costs of subsidising the existing renewable energy support schemes under the Renewables Obligation (RO) (see Practice note, Renewables Obligation) and feed-in tariffs (FITs) (see Feed-in tariffs (FITs) toolkit). The RO will run alongside CFDs during a transitional period (see Practice note, Electricity Market Reform (EMR)).
(Budget Report, paragraph 1.107.)

Capacity market

As a key part of the EMR, the government is introducing a capacity market (CM) to ensure security of energy supply. The CM works by offering all capacity providers (new and existing power stations, electricity storage and demand side electricity reductions) a steady, predictable revenue stream (capacity payments) on which they can base their future investments. In return for the capacity, providers must deliver energy or face financial penalties. The CM is particularly intended to incentivise investment in new gas generating capacity as part of the government's Gas Generation Strategy (see Legal update, DECC publishes Gas Generation Strategy: environmental implications).
The government consulted on the final design of the CM in October 2013. For more information on the October 2013 consultation and on how the CM will function, see Practice note, Electricity Market Reform (EMR): Capacity market.
On 19 March 2014, alongside the 2014 Budget, the Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC) announced the government's final decisions on the CM design, ahead of the first capacity auction that will take place at the end of 2014 (see DECC press release, Electricity Market Reform: Capacity Market design, 19 March 2014).
DECC confirmed that:
  • 15 year capacity agreements will be available to new capacity. This will provide sufficient certainty to unlock investment in new gas plant, which DECC expects will include a range of new independent providers.
  • Existing capacity will be able to access rolling one year agreements. Three year agreements will also be on offer to plants that need to carry out significant refurbishment.
  • Penalties for unreliable capacity will be capped at 200% of a provider's monthly income and 100% of its annual income. This will provide a strong incentive for capacity to be there when needed.
  • The capacity auction will be capped at £75 for each kilowatt to protect consumers from excessive costs.
  • The first capacity auction will take place in December 2014, subject to state aid clearance being received.
  • Capacity will be in place by winter 2018.
  • Two transitional auctions for demand side capacity will be run in 2015 and 2016, to help grow the demand side industry and ensure effective competition between conventional power plants and new forms of capacity (see Legal update, Government invites companies to register for EMR electricity demand reduction pilot project).
  • Prior to the CM being in place, National Grid and Ofgem have already taken action to make certain the lights stay on. National Grid is in the process of contracting new balancing services, either through reserve power plants or capacity provided by voluntary demand reductions, which will be in place by winter 2014, if needed.
DECC indicated that full details of the government's response to the October 2013 consultation on the EMR, including CM design, will be published in late spring 2014, as secondary legislation is put before Parliament.

Climate change levy

CCL main rates

The main climate change levy (CCL) rates will increase in line with the Retail Price Index (RPI) from 1 April 2015.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.166.)

Climate change agreements for sawmilling

The government announced it will add the sawmill sector to the climate change agreements (CCA) scheme by the end of 2014.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.165.)

Shale gas

The government has confirmed that the draft legislation relating to a new tax regime for onshore oil and gas exploration (including shale gas), which it consulted on in December 2013 as part of the Draft Finance Bill 2014, will not be changed when it is included in the final version of the Finance Bill 2014 that will be published on 27 March 2014.
For more information, see:

Carbon capture and storage (CCS)

The government is providing £60 million to support carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies that show significant potential to reduce the cost of low carbon generation in the UK.
(Budget Report, paragraph 1.113.)
For more information on CCS in general, see Practice note, Carbon capture and storage: overview.

Landfill tax

The standard and lower rates of landfill tax will increase in line with the RPI, rounded to the nearest 5 pence, from 1 April 2015.
The government will introduce a loss on ignition testing regime on fines (residual waste from waste processing) from waste transfer stations by April 2015. Only fines below a 10% threshold would be considered eligible for the lower rate. Full proposals will be set out in a consultation later in 2014. The government intends to provide further longer term certainty about the future level of landfill tax rates once the consultation on the testing regime has finished.
The value of the Landfill Communities Fund for 2014-15 will be reduced to £71 million. As a result, the cap on contributions that landfill operators can make will be reduced from 6.8% to 5.1% from 1 April 2014. The saving will be used to fund an equivalent one-off increase to address waste crime. This change is being made by the Landfill Tax (Amendment) Regulations 2014 (SI 2014/707), which were laid before Parliament today (19 March) and will come into force on 1 April 2014.
(Budget Report, paragraphs 2.170-2.171.)
For more information on landfill tax in general, see Practice note, Landfill tax.

Aggregates levy

Rate of aggregates levy

The aggregates levy rate will remain at £2 per tonne in 2014‑15.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.168.)
For more information on the aggregates levy in general, see Practice note, Aggregates levy.

Suspension of exemptions

As confirmed in the 2013 Autumn Statement, the government will include provisions in the Finance Bill 2014 to suspend certain exemptions, exclusions and reliefs from the aggregates levy that are subject to a formal state aid investigation by the European Commission, from 1 April 2014. The legislation will make provision for the suspended elements to be reinstated should the Commission decision allow, and to enable any aggregates levy paid as a result of the suspensions to be repaid where practicable.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.169.)
The government considers that the exemptions in question do not give rise to state aid. However, while the state aid investigation is underway, it is obliged to suspend the exemptions under Article 108(3) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. The government does not know how long the state aid investigation will last.
The government published draft legislation (including draft clauses for the Draft Finance Bill 2014 and related secondary legislation) to introduce the temporary suspension, together with supporting documents, in December 2013. On 19 March 2014, the government published the following documents, which replace those that were published with the draft legislation in December 2013, to reflect minor changes:
The TIIN and guidance include advice to businesses on keeping records to demonstrate that they would not be unjustly enriched by repayment of any aggregates levy paid, if the suspended exemptions are reinstated.
For more information on the:

Zero carbon homes

The government will shortly publish its response to the consultation it carried out in 2013 on allowable solutions for zero carbon homes.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.23.)
For more information on:

Flooding

The government will provide £140 million of new funding in 2014-16 to repair flood defences that have suffered damage in the recent severe flooding.
In autumn 2014, the government will publish a long-term plan for how it will direct the £2.3 billion capital funding from 2015 that was allocated in the Spending Round 2013, to protect the country from future flooding.
(Budget Report, paragraphs 2.27 and 1.133.)
For more information, see:

Enhanced capital allowances (ECAs)

The government will extend the enhanced capital allowance (ECA) for zero emission goods vehicles to 31 March 2018. The ECA will be limited to businesses that do not claim the government's Plug-In Van Grant.
(Budget Report, paragraph 2.109.)
The list of energy-saving and water-efficient technologies that qualify for ECA will be updated in summer 2014, subject to state aid approval.

Fuel poverty

The government will shortly be publishing its proposals for a new fuel poverty target and strategy, which will include looking at the challenges faced by households that are not connected to the gas grid.
(Budget Report, paragraph 1.185.)
For more information on fuel poverty in general, see Practice note, Energy efficiency in buildings: overview: Fuel poverty.

National Infrastructure Plan: finance update

As part of the 2014 Budget, the government has published the National Infrastructure Plan: finance update (NIP Update 2014).
The NIP Update 2014 provides more detail on how the government plans to finance the infrastructure that was announced in the National Infrastructure Plan 2013 (NIP 2013) that was published in December 2013 (see Legal update, National Infrastructure Plan 2013: environmental aspects).
The NIP Update 2014 emphasises that the main debt and equity finance investment (project-specific financing) opportunities are likely to be in electricity generation. This is because the scale of the infrastructure development required means that utility companies are unlikely to fund it themselves on their balance sheets (NIP Update 2014, paragraphs 1.29-1.33). There could therefore be up to £52 billion worth of project financing needed from investors, depending on how much the utility companies choose to finance.
The NIP Update 2014 highlights infrastructure announcements that have already been made, and the potential for project-specific financing, including for:
  • Nuclear. The commercial agreement of the funding of Hinkley Point C was announced in October 2013. The cooperation agreement for Wylfa Newydd was announced in the NIP 2013. The NIP Update 2014 states that project finance opportunities of up to £7.4 billion are likely to be available for investors in these new nuclear power developments before 2020 (NIP Update 2014, paragraphs 1.35-1.37). For more information on nuclear power in general, see Practice note, Proposals for new nuclear power stations: Existing nuclear power stations and proposed new sites.
  • Renewables. There are likely to be substantial opportunities for project-specific financing in offshore wind and other large-scale renewable energy projects. Small-scale renewable energy (such as solar and anaerobic digestion) are more likely to be financed with support from feed-in tariffs (FITs) (NIP Update 2014, paragraphs 1.38-1.41). For more information on renewable energy in general, see Practice note, Renewable energy: overview.
  • Combined-cycle gas turbines (CCGT). The first capacity market (CM) (back up electricity) auction will take place in December 2014. This is part of the wider EMR package. DECC has separately announced details of the CM to coincide with the 2014 Budget (see Capacity market above). The CM will require new gas-fired electricity generating stations to be built. This is likely to need £4.2 billion of investment in new CCGT plant (NIP Update 2014, paragraph 1.42).
  • Carbon capture and storage (CCS). The government notes that it has recently signed front end engineering and design (FEED) agreements with the Peterhead and White Rose CCS projects (see Legal update, Government announces funding for next stage of Peterhead CCS project). There will be opportunities for £1.6 billion worth of financing (NIP Update 2014, paragraph 1.43). For more information on CCS, see Carbon capture and storage (CCS) above.
  • Marine. The government is supporting a number of marine energy demonstration projects, such as the Wave Hub in Cornwall. There is likely to be up to £2.6 billion of investment in commercially-viable marine energy projects in the longer term (NIP Update 2014, paragraph 1.44).
  • Interconnectors. The two routes for interconnector investment (to allow international trade in electricity) are the:
    • regulated route, where interconnector developers have to comply with all aspects of EU legislation and receive a regulated investment return; and
    • merchant-exempt route, where developers would be exempt from EU legislation, but face the full upside and downside of the investment.
    Ofgem is currently developing a new "cap and floor" regulated route for project NEMO (a proposed interconnector between Belgium and Great Britain). However, the merchant-exempt route is historically the approach used in the UK and would generally require project-specific finance, with potential investment opportunities of up to £2.2 billion (NIP Update 2014, paragraphs 1.45-1.46).
  • Biomass. There is £900 million of investment in the pipeline in the biomass sectors up to 2020, all of which may represent a potential project-finance opportunity (NIP Update 2014, paragraph 1.47).

Comment

Given that this may be the penultimate budget before the next general election, the 2014 Budget did not go far towards meeting the Prime Minister's claim that it is "the greenest government ever".
There was wide-spread criticism of the announcement to freeze the CPS so soon after its introduction. Many commentators (from both the conventional and renewables power sector, as well as green groups) criticised the Chancellor for creating policy uncertainty and discouraging investors in renewable energy technologies and gas-fired power generation. There are also fears that the CPS freeze will favour coal-fired power stations and that it will result in increased carbon emissions.
Lord Stern of Brentford suggested that it would have been preferable, instead of freezing the CPS, for the Chancellor to simplify the "existing myriad of policies which have created a complicated and inconsistent system of carbon pricing across the economy".
However, some have welcomed the CPS freeze as it would ease energy bills for businesses and householders. In particular, Tim Yeo MP, chair of the House of Commons Energy and Climate Change Committee, said that the CPS would "actually [do] very little to reduce emissions overall" while it "damaged public trust in taxes on pollution".
Gareth Stace, from manufacturers' organisation EEF, said that the exemptions for EIIs from the RO and other levies for renewable energy would "help to level the playing field [that] these companies need to compete effectively with others around the globe and keep production here in the UK." Conversely, there are concerns that the exemptions will place more of the burden of green levies on household energy bills.
On flooding, there is concern that the funding announced in the 2014 Budget is significantly below the level recommended by independent advisers (see Budget 2014: Critics claim increased flood defence spending fails to hit the mark, BusinessGreen.com, 19 March 2014).

Sources

Further Practical Law analysis of the 2014 Budget

For further analysis from Practical Law of other aspects of the 2014 Budget, see Practical Law: 2014 Budget.