Bespeaks Caution Doctrine | Practical Law

Bespeaks Caution Doctrine | Practical Law

Bespeaks Caution Doctrine

Bespeaks Caution Doctrine

Practical Law Glossary Item w-000-3638 (Approx. 3 pages)

Glossary

Bespeaks Caution Doctrine

A judicially created doctrine that protects issuers of securities and those acting on their behalf from securities fraud claims based on forward-looking statements, if those statements contain adequate cautionary language. The bespeaks caution doctrine holds that forward-looking statements are not misleading if they are accompanied by adequate risk disclosure to caution readers about specific risks that may materially impact the forecasts. (See, for example, Grossman v. Novell, Inc., 120 F.3d 1112, 1120,1123 (10th Cir. 1997).) It applies to:
  • Estimates or other soft information (but not to statements of present or historical facts).
  • Cautionary words about future risk (but not to undisclosed past risk that materialized).
Courts applying the bespeaks caution doctrine generally reason that meaningful cautionary language reduces or negates the reasonableness of reliance on the forward-looking statements and the materiality of those statements. The cautionary language must be meaningful and tailored to the specific issuer, its business and projections. Boilerplate or vague cautionary language does not suffice.